India’s head coach Gautam Gambhir has sparked a big debate in the cricket world by saying that injury replacements in Test cricket should be allowed. His comments came after Rishabh Pant, India’s wicketkeeper-batter, bravely returned to bat despite suffering a fractured foot during the fourth Test match against England in Manchester.
Pant got injured on Day 1 and had to retire hurt, but showed amazing courage by coming back the next day to add 17 more runs. Gambhir called Pant a true warrior and said his bravery should never be forgotten. However, Gambhir also said it’s unfair for a team to continue a Test match with an injured player when no injury replacements in Test cricket are allowed.
On the other hand, England captain Ben Stokes strongly disagrees. He called the idea of injury replacements in Test cricket “absolutely ridiculous” and said it could lead to teams misusing the rule.
Gambhir Supports Injury Substitutes for Test Matches
After Pant’s injury, Gautam Gambhir praised him and said his efforts would inspire future generations of cricketers. But the incident also made Gambhir raise a big question, shouldn’t teams be allowed to bring in injury replacements in Test cricket if a player gets seriously injured?
Gambhir said, “Absolutely, I’m all for it. If the umpires and the match referee see and feel that it’s a major injury, there should be a rule to allow a substitute. Especially in a close series like this, imagine having to play with only 10 fit players against 11.”
Gambhir pointed out that Test cricket is physically demanding, and not having injury replacements in Test cricket can hurt a team’s chances unfairly. He stressed that if the injury is clearly visible, then there’s nothing wrong with giving the team an option to replace that player.
While India were allowed to use Dhruv Jurel as a substitute wicketkeeper, he wasn’t allowed to bat in the second innings. This is because current ICC rules only allow substitutions in cases of concussions or COVID-19. For all other injuries, the team has to manage with their original playing XI, unless injury replacements in Test cricket become a regular rule.
Some cricket boards are planning to test injury replacements in Test cricket at the domestic level later this year, but it’s still not confirmed whether it will be used in international matches.
Ben Stokes Says the Idea is “Ridiculous”
While Gambhir strongly supports the idea, Ben Stokes thinks it’s a bad idea. He believes it would open the door to loopholes and unfair tactics by teams looking to get an advantage through injury replacements in Test cricket.
Stokes said, “I think it’s absolutely ridiculous that there’s even a conversation about injury replacements. There would be too many loopholes that teams could use to their benefit.”
He explained that almost any bowler could go in for a scan and show minor inflammation or strain, and then the team could bring in a fresh player as a replacement. “If you stick me in an MRI scanner, I’d probably find something too,” he joked. “Every fast bowler will show some injury if you look hard enough.”
Stokes made it clear that he agrees with concussion replacements, as player safety is important. But in normal injuries, he thinks teams should accept it as part of the game. “You pick your XI for the game, and you have to deal with whatever happens,” he said.
According to Stokes, keeping injury replacements in Test cricket out of the game protects the true spirit of Test cricket, which is all about facing challenges with the players you selected at the start of the match.
Pant’s Brave Knock and Gambhir’s Tribute
Rishabh Pant has now been ruled out of the fifth and final Test at The Oval starting Thursday. He has been replaced in the squad by N Jagadeesan, but his fearless act will be remembered for years to come.
Pant added 17 more runs after coming back with a broken foot, and Gambhir couldn’t stop praising him. “Not many people in cricket history have done that,” Gambhir said. “He put his hand up and fought for the team. The foundation of this Indian Test team will be built on such moments of bravery.”
Gambhir added, “Any amount of praise is not enough. I could sit here and talk about this for hours. Future generations should know that Pant batted with a broken foot. This shows true character.”
Pant was in excellent form before the injury, and his absence will be a big loss for India. But Gambhir said the team is hopeful that Pant will recover soon and return stronger.
As the debate continues, injury replacements in Test cricket remain a hot topic. While Gambhir supports modernising the game with this change, Stokes stands firmly with tradition. The cricketing world now watches closely to see if injury replacements in Test cricket will become part of the future or stay just a discussion point.
SEE MORE:
