In the high-stakes world of the ICC World Test Championship (WTC), timing is everything, especially when it comes to declarations. A well-timed declaration can pressure the opposition into mistakes, but a misjudged one can turn a near-certain win into a frustrating draw or even a humiliating defeat. With the WTC format turning every Test into a points battle, captains often face a brutal dilemma: set a target early and risk losing, or delay and risk running out of time.
Here are five unforgettable instances in the WTC era where declaration decisions backfired, reshaping not just games but sometimes even the fate of a team’s championship campaign.
5. England vs India – Nottingham, 2021
- Captain: Joe Root
- No formal declaration, but defensive delay on Day 5
- Result: Match Drawn (Rain impacted)
England’s conservative approach with the bat in the second innings on Day 4, delaying the declaration and playing safe, meant India had a likely winning chase of 157 with 9 wickets in hand on Day 5. Unfortunately for India, rain washed out the final day. Had England been bolder earlier, they might have secured a result or forced errors.
Backfire: The weather bailed England out, but it exposed their lack of bold intent, especially in a WTC cycle where wins matter more than avoiding losses.
4. Pakistan vs West Indies – Jamaica, 2021
- Captain: Babar Azam
- Declared at: 176/6 (Target: 329)
- Result: Match Drawn
Pakistan declared, with over four sessions left, thinking they had enough on the board. But West Indies dug deep, with Kraigg Brathwaite anchoring a dogged fourth-innings effort. The late push from Pakistan with defensive fields earlier in the innings meant they couldn’t close out a win.
Backfire: A few more runs or a tighter field setup early on might have given Pakistan a win instead of a draw.
3. Australia vs India – Sydney, 2021
- Captain: Tim Paine
- Declared at: 312/6 (Target: 407)
- Result: Match Drawn
Tim Paine’s timing looked aggressive, but India scripted one of their most heroic draws. A bruised and battered Indian side, missing top players, batted out 131 overs. The declaration, in hindsight, could have come 8–10 overs earlier to squeeze in a result.
Backfire: Australia ran out of time, and India carried the momentum to Brisbane where they sealed the series and a WTC final spot.
2. India vs New Zealand – WTC Final, 2021 (Southampton)
- Captain: Virat Kohli
- Declared at: No declaration – but batted too long in the 2nd innings
- Result: New Zealand won by 8 wickets
While technically not a formal declaration, India’s decision to bat cautiously and slowly in their second innings on a rain-curtailed Day 5 allowed New Zealand enough time to chase a modest 139 on Day 6 (reserve day). Had India been bolder in scoring or declared sooner, the pressure of a target over 180 might have changed the script.
Backfire: Defensive batting rather than a bold declaration turned the tide in New Zealand’s favor, costing India the championship.
1. England vs New Zealand – Lord’s, 2021
- Captain: Joe Root
- Declared at: 170/3 (Target: 273 in 75 overs)
- Result: Match Drawn
England’s decision to declare early on Day 5 against New Zealand was seen as a sporting gesture. However, the Black Caps, eyeing the inaugural WTC Final, refused to take the bait, batting out a comfortable draw. Critics questioned the lack of attacking fields and urgency from England, and the opportunity for a potential home win was wasted.
Backfire: England got neither a win nor a serious chance at it, and New Zealand took valuable WTC momentum to eventually lift the mace.
Final Thoughts
| Match | Captain | Opponent | Year | Declaration Timing / Issue | Target Set | Overs Left | Result | Backfire Summary |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ENG vs NZ (Lord’s) | Joe Root | New Zealand | 2021 | Declared at 170/3 on Day 5 | 273 | 75 | Draw | Batted too long in the 2nd innings (no declaration) |
| IND vs NZ (WTC Final, Southampton) | Virat Kohli | New Zealand | 2021 | India batted 131 overs to pull off a historic draw | 139 (chased) | Full final day | NZ won by 8 wickets | Defensive approach allowed NZ time and ease |
| AUS vs IND (Sydney) | Tim Paine | India | 2021 | Declared at 312/6 | 407 | ~135 | Draw | WI held on; a slightly early declaration cost PAK |
| PAK vs WI (Jamaica) | Babar Azam | West Indies | 2021 | Declared at 176/6 | 329 | ~4.5 sessions | Draw | NZ played for a draw; ENG never in a winning position |
| ENG vs IND (Nottingham) | Joe Root | India | 2021 | Defensive batting on Day 4, no real push | 157 (to chase) | ~90 (lost to rain) | Draw | WI held on; a slightly early declaration cost PAK |
In the WTC format, where every Test impacts the league standings, declaration blunders aren’t just tactical errors, they’re strategic missteps with long-term consequences. Whether driven by caution, misjudgment of conditions, or misplaced aggression, these five instances remind us how delicate the art of declaration is in modern Test cricket.
READ MORE:
