In Test cricket, the pitch often dictates the fate of the match. And when the surface is a rank turner, captains and bowlers alike know spin will play a defining role. A rank turner with dry, cracked surfaces and exaggerated turn from day one is a paradise for spinners and a nightmare for batters. Yet, over the years, there have been shocking moments where captains failed to unleash their most potent weapon: their strike spinner on a rank turner.
Ignoring a spinner on a rank turner is akin to leaving your sword behind in a battle. Whether due to overconfidence in seamers, poor reading of the pitch, internal team politics, or simply tactical blunders, such decisions have cost teams dearly. This article delves into the Top 10 Times Captains Didn’t Bowl Their Strike Spinner on a Rank Turner, revealing how these overlooked decisions led to avoidable losses or missed chances. Let’s unravel these curious cases of cricketing mismanagement, one dusty pitch at a time.
10. England vs Sri Lanka – Galle, 2021 (Captain: Joe Root)
Back in Galle, a venue infamous for being a rank turner, England found themselves with all the cards. But Joe Root’s captaincy left many baffled when he decided to bowl 12 overs himself instead of using Dom Bess, their designated spinner on a rank turner.
Bess had been in fine form, extracting bounce and drift. Yet Root bowled himself through crucial spells on Day 2, while Bess was left underused. Even though England eventually triumphed due to Sri Lanka’s poor batting, Root’s rotation left fans and analysts scratching their heads.
On a Galle pitch with gaping footmarks and puffing dust, not throwing the ball to your spinner on a rank turner was a decision few understood.
Stats Table:
| Match | Venue | Captain | Strike Spinner Ignored | Overs Bowled | Match Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ENG vs SL | Galle, 2021 | Joe Root | Dom Bess | 5 (1st Inn) | England won |
9. Pakistan vs South Africa – Karachi, 2021 (Captain: Babar Azam)
Karachi produced one of its trademark low, slow, and dusty pitches. It was an ideal setting for Yasir Shah, Pakistan’s most successful modern-day leg-spinner and a proven spinner on a rank turner.
Yet, Babar Azam introduced debutant Nauman Ali ahead of Yasir Shah during the crucial early stages of the South African innings. Yasir’s leg-spin, which thrives on bounce and footmarks, was left idle while South Africa capitalised on the inexperience.
Stats Table:
| Match | Venue | Captain | Strike Spinner Ignored | Overs Bowled | Match Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| PAK vs SA | Karachi, 2021 | Babar Azam | Yasir Shah | 4 (early spell) | Pakistan won |
8. India vs Australia – Pune, 2017 (Captain: Virat Kohli)
Pune’s pitch was cracked and dusted from the start. While everyone remembers Steve O’Keefe’s dream spell, few recall that India’s spin strategy was flawed. Jayant Yadav, India’s rising off-spinner at the time, was severely under-bowled.
On a surface that begged for a spinner on a rank turner, Kohli over-relied on Ashwin and Jadeja, exhausting them over long spells. Yadav bowled just 3 overs in the second innings, an astonishing number for a turning track.
Stats Table:
| Match | Venue | Captain | Strike Spinner Ignored | Overs Bowled | Match Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| IND vs AUS | Pune, 2017 | Virat Kohli | Jayant Yadav | 3 (2nd Inn) | Australia won |
7. West Indies vs Pakistan – Barbados, 2021 (Captain: Kraigg Brathwaite)
The Kensington Oval pitch in Barbados had long shown signs of wear and tear when the West Indies faced Pakistan in 2021. As expected, it started to take a significant turn by the second day. With the stage set for spin dominance, Kraigg Brathwaite chose to rely heavily on his seamers.
Rahkeem Cornwall, West Indies’ burly off-spinner and their only spinner on a rank turner, was surprisingly under-bowled. While Babar Azam and Fawad Alam stitched a patient partnership, Cornwall was seen warming up on the boundary rather than bowling.
Stats Table:
| Match | Venue | Captain | Strike Spinner Ignored | Overs Bowled | Match Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| WI vs PAK | Barbados, 2021 | K. Brathwaite | Rahkeem Cornwall | 11 (1st Inn) | Pakistan won |
6. India vs England – Chennai, 2021 (Captain: Joe Root)
In this infamous Test at Chennai, the pitch began turning sharply from the first session. India’s spinners Axar Patel and R. Ashwin ran riot, but England didn’t reciprocate. Jack Leach, who had bowled impressively in the previous match, was barely used in crucial passages of play.
Instead, Joe Root brought in Moeen Ali far more, despite his inconsistency. Leach, who should have been the go-to spinner on a rank turner, bowled only 12 overs in the first innings. India amassed a solid total, largely untouched by any consistent spin pressure from England.
Stats Table:
| Match | Venue | Captain | Strike Spinner Ignored | Overs Bowled | Match Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| IND vs ENG | Chennai, 2021 | Joe Root | Jack Leach | 12 (1st Inn) | India won |
5. Bangladesh vs Afghanistan – Chattogram, 2019 (Captain: Shakib Al Hasan)
In one of the biggest upsets in Test cricket, Afghanistan defeated Bangladesh on their soil and on a rank turner, no less. What made the loss even more shocking was Shakib Al Hasan’s questionable captaincy, particularly his handling of Taijul Islam.
As the track crumbled from Day 1, the need for an experienced spinner on a rank turner was obvious. But Shakib persisted with seamers and his left-arm spin for much of the early stages. Taijul, despite being Bangladesh’s most potent spinner on a rank turner, was brought on very late.
Stats Table:
| Match | Venue | Captain | Strike Spinner Ignored | Overs Bowled | Match Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| BAN vs AFG | Chattogram, 2019 | Shakib Al Hasan | Taijul Islam | 7 (1st Inn) | Afghanistan won |
4. Australia vs India – Sydney, 2008 (Captain: Ricky Ponting)
Sydney, in 2008, offered something rarely seen in Australia: a surface that turned viciously by Day 3. The footmarks created by left-arm quicks were tailor-made for a left-arm spinner on a rank turner. Yet, Ricky Ponting, despite having Brad Hogg in his lineup, chose not to exploit these conditions.
Instead of unleashing Hogg early on Day 3, Ponting turned to his seamers and defensive tactics. Hogg, Australia’s main spinner on a rank turner, bowled just 9 overs while the pitch deteriorated. This defensive approach allowed Tendulkar and Laxman to bat freely and take the game away.
Stats Table:
| Match | Venue | Captain | Strike Spinner Ignored | Overs Bowled | Match Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| AUS vs IND | Sydney, 2008 | Ricky Ponting | Brad Hogg | 9 (Day 3) | Australia won controversially |
3. Sri Lanka vs Australia – Galle, 2022 (Captain: Dimuth Karunaratne)
Galle is notorious for being a rank turner’s haven. From Day 1, the pitch was spitting venom. Yet, Sri Lankan skipper Dimuth Karunaratne made a perplexing call by holding back Ramesh Mendis, his best spinner on a rank turner until after the Australian openers had weathered the early storm.
Instead of deploying Mendis early to extract bounce and turn from the crusting surface, Karunaratne bowled part-timers and medium pacers in the opening spells. By the time Mendis came into the attack, Australia’s top order had already laid a stable foundation. Sri Lanka played catch-up throughout and lost a match they could have dominated.
Stats Table:
| Match | Venue | Captain | Strike Spinner Ignored | Overs Bowled | Match Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SL vs AUS | Galle, 2022 | D. Karunaratne | Ramesh Mendis | 4 (early overs) | Australia won |
2. England vs India – The Oval, 2021 (Captain: Joe Root)
As India mounted a historic fourth-innings chase of 368 runs at The Oval, the pitch began to break up noticeably. Cracks were opening, footmarks were growing wider, and rough patches near the batting crease offered exaggerated turn. It was a textbook case of a rank turner emerging late in the match.
England had Moeen Ali their most experienced spinner on a rank turner in their ranks. Yet surprisingly, Joe Root chose to underutilise him. Moeen bowled just 6 overs in the final innings, even though turn and bounce were both visible. Instead, Root persisted with seamers and bowled himself for 12 overs.
Stats Table:
| Match | Venue | Captain | Strike Spinner Ignored | Overs Bowled | Match Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ENG vs IND | The Oval, 2021 | Joe Root | Moeen Ali | 6 (2nd Inn) | India won |
1. India vs South Africa – Nagpur, 2015 (Captain: Virat Kohli)
The 2015 Nagpur Test was infamously dubbed a “minefield” by critics, with spin dominating from the first session. Yet, surprisingly, Ravindra Jadeja, India’s most effective spinner on a rank turner, was under-bowled in the first innings. Kohli opted to persist with part-time spin options and seamers early on, allowing South Africa to scrape through to a fighting total.
Had Jadeja been used earlier, the collapse could’ve come quicker. It wasn’t until the second innings that he showed his full potential, picking up 5 wickets on a crumbling surface.
Stats Table:
| Match | Venue | Captain | Strike Spinner Ignored | Overs Bowled | Match Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| IND vs SA | Nagpur, 2015 | Virat Kohli | Ravindra Jadeja | 12 (1st Inn) | India won |
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. What is a rank turner in cricket?
A rank turner is a pitch that offers excessive turn from day one, often favouring spinners heavily due to dryness and cracks.
2. Why do captains sometimes ignore their spinner on a rank turner?
Captains may misread conditions, over-rely on seamers, follow rigid plans, or bow to internal team dynamics, even on spin-friendly tracks.
3. Which famous Test was lost due to ignoring a spinner on a rank turner?
England’s 2021 loss to India in Chennai is a prime example, where Jack Leach was under-bowled despite turning conditions.
4. How can captains better manage spinners on turning tracks?
By trusting their strike spinner early, exploiting rough patches, and rotating spin from both ends to build pressure.
5. Do rank turners make Test cricket less fair?
Debatable. While they challenge batters immensely, they add diversity to conditions and reward spin skills, an integral part of cricket.
READ MORE:
