The Top 5 Highest Scoring Goalkeepers in FPL 2025/26 have played a crucial role in shaping Fantasy Premier League squads this season. While attackers often receive most of the attention, goalkeepers have quietly accumulated valuable points through clean sheets, saves, bonus points, and consistent performances.
The Top 5 Highest Scoring Goalkeepers in FPL 2025/26 feature a combination of experienced Premier League stars and exciting new arrivals who have exceeded expectations. Whether you invested in a premium goalkeeper or opted for a budget gem, the right choice between the posts has often been the difference between a green arrow and a red arrow.
In this article, we rank the Top 5 Highest Scoring Goalkeepers in FPL 2025/26, complete with their season highlights, FPL statistics, and why they became must-have assets for fantasy managers.
1. David Raya – Arsenal (162 Points)
David Raya comfortably finishes first among the Top 5 Highest Scoring Goalkeepers in FPL 2025/26 with an outstanding 162 points.
Arsenal’s exceptional defensive record provided the perfect platform for Raya, but it was his own consistency that separated him from the competition. Week after week, the Spanish goalkeeper delivered clean sheets, crucial saves, and valuable bonus points.
Managers who selected Raya early in the season enjoyed one of the most dependable fantasy assets available. His calmness, distribution, and ability to make decisive saves ensured he remained the highest-scoring goalkeeper throughout the campaign.
David Raya FPL Stats
| Category | Statistics |
|---|---|
| Club | Arsenal |
| Nationality | Spain |
| FPL Points | 162 |
| Position | Goalkeeper |
| Strength | Clean Sheets, Saves & Bonus Points |
The Top 5 Highest Scoring Goalkeepers in FPL 2025/26 are led by Raya, who set the benchmark for fantasy goalkeeping excellence this season.
ALSO READ:
2. Caoimhín Kelleher – Brentford (143 Points)
After becoming Brentford’s first-choice goalkeeper, Caoimhín Kelleher enjoyed the finest season of his Premier League career.
His composure under pressure, sharp reflexes, and excellent ball distribution suited Brentford’s tactical approach perfectly. Combined with the club’s solid defensive record, Kelleher consistently produced clean sheets, save points, and bonus returns.
Many FPL managers regarded him as one of the transfers of the season due to his impressive consistency.
Caoimhín Kelleher FPL Stats
| Category | Statistics |
|---|---|
| Club | Brentford |
| Nationality | Republic of Ireland |
| FPL Points | 143 |
| Position | Goalkeeper |
| Strength | Clean Sheets & Bonus Points |
The Top 5 Highest Scoring Goalkeepers in FPL 2025/26 highlight Kelleher as one of the season’s biggest success stories.
3. Robin Roefs – Sunderland (136 Points)
Robin Roefs emerged as one of the biggest surprises of the 2025/26 Fantasy Premier League season. Playing for newly promoted Sunderland, the young goalkeeper quickly established himself as one of the league’s best budget options.
Facing plenty of shots throughout the campaign allowed Roefs to accumulate a huge number of save points, while Sunderland’s disciplined defending also delivered several valuable clean sheets.
His affordability and consistency made him one of the smartest budget investments of the season.
Robin Roefs FPL Stats
| Category | Statistics |
|---|---|
| Club | Sunderland |
| Nationality | Netherlands |
| FPL Points | 136 |
| Position | Goalkeeper |
| Strength | Save Points & Budget Value |
Among the Top 5 Highest Scoring Goalkeepers in FPL 2025/26, Roefs was arguably the best value-for-money goalkeeper.
4. Jordan Pickford – Everton (135 Points)
Jordan Pickford once again proved why he remains one of Fantasy Premier League’s safest goalkeeper picks. Everton’s defensive organization underpinned another productive season, allowing Pickford to register numerous clean sheets while maintaining a high save count.
His experience, leadership, and ability to deliver bonus-point performances in tight matches made him one of the most reliable long-term options for fantasy managers.
Jordan Pickford FPL Stats
| Category | Statistics |
|---|---|
| Club | Everton |
| Nationality | England |
| FPL Points | 135 |
| Position | Goalkeeper |
| Strength | Clean Sheets & Save Points |
The Top 5 Highest Scoring Goalkeepers in FPL 2025/26 include Pickford thanks to another season of remarkable consistency.
5. Gianluigi Donnarumma – Manchester City (135 Points)
Italian international Gianluigi Donnarumma enjoyed an impressive debut Premier League campaign with Manchester City. His commanding presence, quick reflexes, and excellent distribution helped him become one of the standout fantasy goalkeepers despite City’s occasional defensive inconsistencies.
Donnarumma regularly earned save points in difficult fixtures while also collecting bonus points whenever he produced match-winning performances. His ability to perform under pressure made him a dependable FPL asset throughout the campaign.
Gianluigi Donnarumma FPL Stats
| Category | Statistics |
|---|---|
| Club | Manchester City |
| Nationality | Italy |
| FPL Points | 135 |
| Position | Goalkeeper |
| Strength | Saves, Bonus Points & Distribution |
The Top 5 Highest Scoring Goalkeepers in FPL 2025/26 would not be complete without Donnarumma, whose performances justified his premium price.
Top 5 Highest Scoring Goalkeepers in FPL 2025/26
| Rank | Goalkeeper | Club | FPL Points |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | David Raya | Arsenal | 162 |
| 2 | Caoimhín Kelleher | Brentford | 143 |
| 3 | Robin Roefs | Sunderland | 136 |
| 4 | Jordan Pickford | Everton | 135 |
| 5 | Gianluigi Donnarumma | Manchester City | 135 |
The Top 5 Highest Scoring Goalkeepers in FPL 2025/26 demonstrate that consistency is just as important as explosive returns. Here’s a closer look at each goalkeeper.
Conclusion
The Top 5 Highest Scoring Goalkeepers in FPL 2025/26 showcased the importance of choosing the right goalkeeper strategy. David Raya dominated the rankings through Arsenal’s outstanding defensive performances, while Caoimhín Kelleher delivered excellent consistency for Brentford. Robin Roefs emerged as the breakout budget star, and experienced campaigners Jordan Pickford and Gianluigi Donnarumma completed an impressive top five.
Whether managers preferred premium reliability or affordable value, the Top 5 Highest Scoring Goalkeepers in FPL 2025/26 demonstrated that goalkeepers can be season-defining fantasy assets. As the campaign comes to a close, these five shot-stoppers have earned their place among the best performers in Fantasy Premier League.
FAQs
1. Who was the highest-scoring goalkeeper in FPL 2025/26?
David Raya of Arsenal finished as the highest-scoring goalkeeper with 162 Fantasy Premier League points.
2. Which budget goalkeeper performed best in FPL 2025/26?
Robin Roefs of Sunderland emerged as one of the best budget goalkeeper options, finishing with 136 FPL points.
3. Why were goalkeepers so valuable in FPL 2025/26?
Goalkeepers earned points through clean sheets, saves, bonus points, and consistent performances, making them crucial assets for successful Fantasy Premier League teams.
SEE MORE:
