Cricket is a game of glorious uncertainties. Nowhere is that uncertainty more jarring than when captains, often the backbone of their team, fail not just once but twice in the same Test match. The phrase “captains were dismissed for a duck” strikes a rare and cruel chord in the annals of Test cricket. These are the men chosen to lead, strategise, and inspire. Yet, under the weight of expectation or the brilliance of opposition bowlers, they sometimes crumble. And when captains were dismissed for a duck in both innings, the ripple effect on team morale and match outcome is often disastrous.
This list dives deep into the top 10 instances in Test history where captains were dismissed for a duck in both innings, moments that left fans stunned and scorecards haunting. Some of these matches turned into dramatic collapses, while others saw spirited team performances despite the captain’s misfortune. What unites them all is the eerie echo of zero beside a name that usually commands respect.
10. Kane Williamson vs England – 2021, Leeds
When modern greats falter, it shocks the fans. Kane Williamson, a paragon of calm, fell for ducks in both innings during a Test at Headingley. Anderson and Robinson exposed his slight technical lapse, ensuring that captains were dismissed for a duck even in the age of DRS and analytics.
Match Impact: New Zealand’s batting collapsed around Kane’s twin failures, and England roared back into the series.
| Player | Team | Opponent | Venue | Year | Innings 1 | Innings 2 | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kane Williamson | New Zealand | England | Leeds | 2021 | 0 (5) | 0 (2) | England won by 7 wickets |
9. Sourav Ganguly vs South Africa – 2002, Bloemfontein
Even “Dada” wasn’t immune. Facing a rejuvenated South African attack, Ganguly fell for ducks in both innings. It was one of the few cases where captains were dismissed for a duck, and yet the fighting spirit remained high, especially in India’s bowling unit.
Match Impact: Though India lost, young talents like Sehwag and Harbhajan showed promise.
| Player | Team | Opponent | Venue | Year | Innings 1 | Innings 2 | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sourav Ganguly | India | South Africa | Bloemfontein | 2002 | 0 (6) | 0 (4) | South Africa won by 9 wickets |
8. Nasser Hussain vs Australia – 2002, Brisbane
In the Ashes opener of 2002, Nasser Hussain’s decision to bowl first is infamous, but his performance was just as forgettable. The instance where captains were dismissed for a duck added salt to England’s wounds. Brett Lee had his number, and Nasser couldn’t open his account in either innings.
Match Impact: Australia posted 492/9 declared and steamrolled England thereafter.
| Player | Team | Opponent | Venue | Year | Innings 1 | Innings 2 | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nasser Hussain | England | Australia | Brisbane | 2002 | 0 (3) | 0 (1) | Australia won by an innings and 118 runs |
7. Brian Lara vs South Africa – 1999, Port Elizabeth
Known for his artistry, Lara had a nightmare in PE. Facing Allan Donald and Shaun Pollock, the stylish left-hander bagged a pair, leaving the cricketing world stunned. It was one of the most shocking cases where captains were dismissed for a duck in both innings.
Match Impact: West Indies fell apart in both innings and handed South Africa an easy win.
| Player | Team | Opponent | Venue | Year | Innings 1 | Innings 2 | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Brian Lara | West Indies | South Africa | Port Elizabeth | 1999 | 0 (1) | 0 (2) | South Africa won by an innings and 100 runs |
6. Shaun Pollock vs Sri Lanka – 2000, Galle
When captains were dismissed for a duck, the pressure often shifted rapidly. Pollock’s twin failures on a raging turner in Galle were exploited by Muralitharan, who spun webs of doom.
Match Impact: Sri Lanka capitalised fully, with Jayasuriya and Sangakkara leading with the bat to secure a dominant win.
| Player | Team | Opponent | Venue | Year | Innings 1 | Innings 2 | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shaun Pollock | South Africa | Sri Lanka | Galle | 2000 | 0 (4) | 0 (5) | Sri Lanka won by 10 wickets |
5. Wasim Akram vs Australia – 1995, Brisbane
Even legendary all-rounders have their off days. Wasim Akram, one of Pakistan’s most iconic captains, succumbed twice without scoring against a fearsome Australian pace attack. When captains were dismissed for a duck, it echoed louder given Akram’s stature.
Match Impact: Pakistan never recovered from Akram’s failures as McGrath and Warne dictated terms.
| Player | Team | Opponent | Venue | Year | Innings 1 | Innings 2 | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Wasim Akram | Pakistan | Australia | Brisbane | 1995 | 0 (6) | 0 (3) | Australia won by an innings and 126 runs |
4. Alec Stewart vs West Indies – 1995, Bridgetown
The Caribbean quicks were unforgiving. When captains were dismissed for a duck in both innings, Alec Stewart learned it the hard way in Barbados. Ambrose and Walsh ran riot, with Stewart falling cheaply in both innings without disturbing the scorers.
Match Impact: England folded meekly, unable to put up any resistance, as the Windies won with ease.
| Player | Team | Opponent | Venue | Year | Innings 1 | Innings 2 | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Alec Stewart | England | West Indies | Bridgetown | 1995 | 0 (5) | 0 (1) | West Indies won by 8 wickets |
3. Michael Clarke vs India – 2013, Hyderabad
It’s rare for Michael Clarke to miss out, especially on Indian soil, where his footwork was praised. But when captains were dismissed for a duck in both innings of the Hyderabad Test, Clarke joined an unwanted club. Ravindra Jadeja and Ashwin dismantled Clarke’s defences twice, ensuring Australia’s downfall.
Match Impact: Australia collapsed in both innings, eventually losing the match heavily, and Clarke’s twin ducks became symbolic of the touring side’s woes.
| Player | Team | Opponent | Venue | Year | Innings 1 | Innings 2 | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Michael Clarke | Australia | India | Hyderabad | 2013 | 0 (4) | 0 (2) | India won by an innings and 135 runs |
2. Graeme Smith vs India – 2008, Ahmedabad
When captains were dismissed for a duck in both innings on a spin-friendly Indian pitch, Graeme Smith’s misery became a headline. Kumble’s aggressive field placements and Harbhajan’s clever turn sent the South African skipper packing in both innings without scoring. Smith, known for his grit, had no answers to the subcontinental spin web.
Match Impact: Fortunately for Smith, his teammates rallied with a mammoth first-innings score and dismissed India cheaply twice to record a memorable win.
| Player | Team | Opponent | Venue | Year | Innings 1 | Innings 2 | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Graeme Smith | South Africa | India | Ahmedabad | 2008 | 0 (3) | 0 (7) | South Africa won by an innings and 90 runs |
1. Andrew Strauss vs Pakistan – 2010, The Oval
In one of the most bizarre Test matches of the modern era, England’s captain Andrew Strauss endured a horror outing as both innings yielded a golden duck. Facing Mohammad Aamer and Mohammad Asif on a cloudy Oval pitch, Strauss was undone by two sensational spells. This was a match already steeped in tension, and the fact that the captains were dismissed for a duck here set the tone for England’s struggle.
Match Impact: Despite Strauss’ failure, England managed to eke out a competitive total, but the psychological damage was done. The match would later be remembered more for the spot-fixing scandal.
| Player | Team | Opponent | Venue | Year | Innings 1 | Innings 2 | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Andrew Strauss | England | Pakistan | The Oval | 2010 | 0 (1) | 0 (2) | Pakistan won by 4 wickets |
READ MORE:
