The Indian Premier League is a melting pot of talent, pressure, and unpredictability. While some players carve out legendary careers through consistent brilliance, a few carve their names into memory through something far more peculiar: performing like absolute superstars, but only against one specific team.
It’s one of cricket’s strangest but most fascinating trends: a player who seems ordinary all season suddenly turns into a match-winner but only when a certain jersey is on the other side. Maybe it’s a psychological edge, maybe it’s a technical matchup, or maybe it’s just destiny scripting drama in cricket’s most-watched league.
In this blog, we dive deep into the Top 5 Players Who Reserved Their Best Only for One Opponent, the one-team wonders whose IPL tales are defined by a strange and ruthless fixation with a single franchise. You won’t believe some of these numbers.
5. Manish Pandey vs Chennai Super Kings
Known As: The “One-Off Lion Slayer”
- Runs vs CSK: 458
- Average: 41.6
- Strike Rate: 139.2
- Best: 83*
Against Other Teams:
- Average: 25.4
- Strike Rate: 119.7
Highlight:
Manish Pandey has often struggled with consistency. But he regularly turns up against the men in yellow, whether it’s anchoring a chase or playing the counterattack. His standout innings in high-pressure games, especially when he was a part of Kolkata Knight Riders vs CSK, made him a specialist against Dhoni’s side.
4. Amit Mishra vs Deccan Chargers / SRH
Known As: The “Hyderabad Specialist”
- Wickets vs DC/SRH: 31
- Best Figures: 5/17
- Hat-tricks: 2
Against Other Teams:
- Wickets per game: Lower
- Strike Rate: Higher
Highlight:
Amit Mishra’s two hat-tricks against the Deccan Chargers and the Sunrisers Hyderabad show a strange pattern of domination. His leg-spin seemed particularly lethal in Hyderabad’s slower tracks, making him their consistent tormentor.
3. Yusuf Pathan vs Mumbai Indians
Known As: MI’s “Unwelcome Guest”
- Runs vs MI: 446
- Average: 39.5
- Strike Rate: 158.9
- Best: 72 off 22 balls
Against Other Teams:
- Average: 24.1
- Strike Rate: 132.6
Highlight:
Yusuf’s most explosive knocks, including that 72(22) blitzkrieg, came against Mumbai. His power-hitting always found a new gear at Wankhede or against MI bowlers. Against others, he was much more inconsistent.
2. Sandeep Sharma vs RCB
Known As: The “Kohli-Killer”
- Wickets vs RCB: 15
- Economy Rate: 6.9
- Average: 17.4
- Best: 3/19
Against Other Teams:
- Economy Rate: 8.4
- Average: 28.6
Highlight:
Sandeep Sharma seems to have a personal vendetta against Royal Challengers Bengaluru. His repeated dismissals of Virat Kohli (7 times across all formats) and miserly spells have made him RCB’s nightmare. His swing and length seem tailor-made to exploit their top order.
1. Rahul Tewatia vs Punjab Kings
Known As: The “Punjab Punisher”
- Matches vs PBKS: 8
- Runs: 236
- Average: 59.0
- Strike Rate: 169.1
- Best: 53* (2020)
Against Other Teams:
- Average: 16.7
- Strike Rate: 121.4
Highlight:
That iconic 2020 innings in Sharjah, where Tewatia smashed Sheldon Cottrell for five sixes in an over to pull off a miraculous win, remains etched in IPL folklore. Interestingly, he has repeatedly shown his best finishing skills against Punjab, while remaining largely ineffective against most other sides.
Final Thoughts
In a league as unpredictable and electrifying as the IPL, every player carries a story, but some carry a very specific one. These rare one-team wonders may not light up every match, but when a particular opposition shows up, it’s as if something inside them clicks. The bat flows freer, the ball obeys their command, and the scoreboard tilts in their favour. Are these patterns mere coincidences? Or do they hint at hidden rivalries, strategic matchups, or mental edges built over time? Perhaps it’s just the thrill of proving a point again and again, to one team that underestimated them.
Whatever the reason, these unique dynamics make the IPL far more than just a battle of bat and ball. They create narratives within narratives, personal duels, silent feuds, and unexpected heroes. And as fans, we live for these moments when a forgotten player suddenly turns giant-slayer, but only against that one team. Because in the IPL, it’s not just about how well you play sometimes, it’s who you play that defines your legacy.
READ MORE:
