In the Indian Premier League (IPL), assembling a team brimming with cricketing icons is often seen as a shortcut to success. With multi-million-dollar auctions, aggressive bidding wars, and careful retention strategies, franchises go all out to stack their lineups with match-winners. However, as history shows, even the most star-studded squads can spectacularly collapse under the weight of expectations.
A team may boast world-class openers, experienced all-rounders, and international bowling spearheads, but it still needs cohesion, balance, smart leadership, and a bit of luck to make it to the playoffs. Over the years, the IPL has witnessed numerous such instances where a team glittered on paper but crumbled on the pitch. This list revisits the 5 unforgettable cases where elite squads failed to live up to their billing, crashing out before even making the top four.
1. Delhi Capitals – IPL 2014
Key Players:
- Kevin Pietersen – One of England’s greatest modern-day batsmen, explosive and unpredictable, KP was named captain and brand ambassador of this new-look Delhi squad.
- Dinesh Karthik – Bought for a whopping ₹12.5 crore, he was expected to anchor the innings and guide the Indian core.
- JP Duminy – A T20 veteran with composure and class in the middle order.
- Quinton de Kock – Young, aggressive, and in great form on the international circuit.
- Mohammad Shami – India’s pace spearhead, offering death-over control and new-ball swing.
What Happened:
Delhi Daredevils (now Capitals) made wholesale changes after a disastrous 2013. They came in with renewed optimism, but their campaign derailed almost immediately. Pietersen missed the first few games due to injury, and the team kept chopping and changing their playing XI. Karthik failed to justify his massive price tag, and none of the foreign stars stood up when it mattered.
Final Standing: 8th (2 wins in 14 matches)
Key Issues: Lack of direction, no momentum, questionable team selections, and underwhelming local talent.
2. Royal Challengers Bangalore – IPL 2017
Key Players:
- Virat Kohli – Coming off a historic 973-run season in 2016, he was the heart and soul of RCB.
- AB de Villiers – Mr. 360 himself, capable of winning games single-handedly.
- Chris Gayle – The Universe Boss, feared across formats.
- Shane Watson – A proven all-rounder and match-winner.
- Tymal Mills – Bought for ₹12 crore for his left-arm pace and T20 skills.
- KL Rahul – Ruled out due to injury before the season began.
What Happened:
RCB was expected to steamroll the opposition, but the team collapsed early. Kohli and ABD missed the initial matches due to injury. Gayle was woefully out of form, and Watson couldn’t find his rhythm. Mills flattered to deceive. The bowling lacked bite, and the team’s over-dependence on their top 3 was brutally exposed.
They were bowled out for 49, the lowest score in IPL history by KKR, a moment that summed up their forgettable season.
Final Standing: 8th (3 wins in 14 matches)
Key Issues: Injuries, imbalance, poor domestic bowling strength, and zero backup plans.
3. Mumbai Indians – IPL 2022
Key Players:
- Rohit Sharma – The most successful IPL captain with five titles.
- Ishan Kishan – Bought for ₹15.25 crore, expected to deliver aggressive starts.
- Suryakumar Yadav – One of India’s most dependable T20 batters.
- Kieron Pollard – MI’s long-time finisher and emotional core.
- Jasprit Bumrah – Arguably the best T20 bowler in the world.
- Jofra Archer – Retained despite being unavailable for the season.
What Happened:
Mumbai Indians began the season with eight consecutive losses, their worst ever start. Rohit and Kishan failed to fire consistently, and Pollard looked like a shadow of his former self. SKY missed a few games and carried the burden alone when he played. The spin attack was ineffective, and Bumrah had to carry the entire bowling lineup.
Final Standing: 10th (4 wins in 14 matches)
Key Issues: Missing Archer, out-of-form senior players, no match-winning spinner, and poor lower-order finishing.
4. Kolkata Knight Riders – IPL 2009
Key Players:
- Brendon McCullum – Took over as captain from Ganguly.
- Chris Gayle – At his destructive best in world cricket at the time.
- Sourav Ganguly – Demoted from captaincy, yet still a towering figure.
- Ishant Sharma – India’s pace poster boy.
- Ajantha Mendis – The mystery spinner everyone feared in 2009.
What Happened:
KKR’s 2009 campaign was dominated by John Buchanan’s controversial “multiple captains” strategy. This destabilised team unity and angered fans. Despite having explosive openers and a quality bowling core, the team looked confused and underprepared. Ganguly was sidelined, McCullum struggled under pressure, and the management’s tactics baffled everyone.
Final Standing: 8th (3 wins in 14 matches)
Key Issues: Dysfunctional leadership, zero chemistry, off-field chaos, and strategic misfires.
5. Sunrisers Hyderabad – IPL 2021
Key Players:
- David Warner – SRH’s long-time captain and IPL legend.
- Kane Williamson – Calm, composed, and tactically brilliant.
- Jonny Bairstow – Explosive opener who has been consistently impactful.
- Rashid Khan – The world’s premier T20 spinner.
- Bhuvneshwar Kumar – India’s swing king.
What Happened:
Midway through the season, SRH made the shocking decision to strip Warner of captaincy and drop him from the XI. The move signalled internal rifts. Williamson took over, but the batting lineup lacked punch and consistency. While the bowling remained competitive, the batters failed to post or chase defendable totals. Frequent changes in the lineup created more instability.
Final Standing: 8th (3 wins in 14 matches)
Key Issues: Poor management decisions, instability in leadership, a misfiring middle-order, and a lack of finishing firepower.
READ MORE:
